The End of Double-Mindedness
James 4:7-17
Submit yourselves therefore to God. Resist the devil, and he will flee from you. Draw near to God, and he will draw near to you. Cleanse your hands, you sinners, and purify your hearts, you double-minded. Be wretched and mourn and weep. Let your laughter be turned to mourning and your joy to gloom. Humble yourselves before the Lord, and he will exalt you.
Do not speak evil against one another, brothers. The one who speaks against a brother or judges his brother, speaks evil against the law and judges the law. But if you judge the law, you are not a doer of the law but a judge. There is only one lawgiver and judge, he who is able to save and to destroy. But who are you to judge your neighbor?
Come now, you who say, “Today or tomorrow we will go into such and such a town and spend a year there and trade and make a profit”— yet you do not know what tomorrow will bring. What is your life? For you are a mist that appears for a little time and then vanishes. Instead you ought to say, “If the Lord wills, we will live and do this or that.” As it is, you boast in your arrogance. All such boasting is evil. So whoever knows the right thing to do and fails to do it, for him it is sin.
Do not speak evil against one another, brothers. The one who speaks against a brother or judges his brother, speaks evil against the law and judges the law. But if you judge the law, you are not a doer of the law but a judge. There is only one lawgiver and judge, he who is able to save and to destroy. But who are you to judge your neighbor?
Come now, you who say, “Today or tomorrow we will go into such and such a town and spend a year there and trade and make a profit”— yet you do not know what tomorrow will bring. What is your life? For you are a mist that appears for a little time and then vanishes. Instead you ought to say, “If the Lord wills, we will live and do this or that.” As it is, you boast in your arrogance. All such boasting is evil. So whoever knows the right thing to do and fails to do it, for him it is sin.
James continues to confront us with the harsh truth. We're really good at dividing our loyalties. We want God's blessing, but we also want the world's approval. We desire spiritual depth, but we chase material success. We claim to follow Jesus, yet we live as if we're the ones in control. This double-mindedness, as James calls it, isn't a minor character flaw. It's spiritual adultery. The opening verses of James 4 paint a picture of believers who've become friends with the world and enemies of God. In verses 7 through 17, he offers the path back to authentic faith. He shows us what it means to worship God in spirit and in truth.
The passage begins with a word that carries military weight. "Submit yourselves therefore to God." The Greek word here, hypotagete, was used to describe soldiers voluntarily arranging themselves under the authority of their commanding officer. This isn't coerced obedience but closer to a willing surrender. We choose to place ourselves under God's command because we recognize His rightful authority over our lives. Using the word "therefore," James is building on what he's just said about God giving grace to the humble. Submission flows from grace. We don't submit to earn God's favor. We submit because God has already shown us favor through Christ. This should impact the way that we approach spiritual disciplines and obedience.
The call to submit comes paired with another command. "Resist the devil, and he will flee from you." We can't resist the enemy in our own strength. That's the crucial connection. Submission to God precedes effective resistance against Satan. When we're under God's authority, we have access to His power. The devil must flee when confronted by someone who's aligned with God. This isn't complicated spiritual warfare theology. It's practical reality. The Christian life involves real spiritual opposition. But we're not left to fight alone or in our own power. We stand firm in God's authority, and the enemy has to retreat. He has no choice in the matter. Then James gives us this beautiful promise. "Draw near to God, and he will draw near to you." This is the language of the temple, of priests approaching the presence of the Lord. But under the new covenant, all believers have access to God's presence through Christ. When we move toward God, He moves toward us. This is relationship, not ritual. The question is whether we're actually drawing near. Are we spending time in prayer? Are we reading Scripture? Are we worshiping? Or are we treating God like a cosmic vending machine, approaching Him only when we need something? Drawing near means cultivating an ongoing relationship with the Lord. It means making space in our lives for Him.
But drawing near requires honesty about our condition. James doesn't mince words. "Cleanse your hands, you sinners, and purify your hearts, you double-minded." He's addressing the external and the internal. Our actions need to change. Our motives need to change. We can't clean ourselves, but we must come to God for cleansing. That word "double-minded" appears only in James. It literally means "two-souled" or "two-minded." It describes someone trying to serve two masters, attempting to have God and the world simultaneously. Jesus said this is impossible. You'll love one and hate the other. You'll be devoted to one and despise the other. Double-mindedness produces instability and spiritual disaster. The call to repentance intensifies. "Be wretched and mourn and weep. Let your laughter be turned to mourning and your joy to gloom." This sounds harsh to modern ears. We live in a culture that avoids guilt at all costs. We're told that any negative emotion about our sin is unhealthy. But Scripture presents a different picture.
Godly sorrow over sin is the path to genuine joy. When we truly see our sin for what it is, when we understand how it grieves God and damages our souls, appropriate grief follows. This isn't morbid introspection or self-hatred. It's honest assessment. It's taking sin seriously because God takes it seriously. The world offers a different kind of laughter and joy. It's the celebration of rebellion, the pride of self-sufficiency, the arrogance of thinking we know better than God. That laughter needs to stop. That false joy needs to be exposed for what it is. Only then can we experience the deep, lasting joy that comes from right relationship with God.
James concludes this section with a promise. "Humble yourselves before the Lord, and he will exalt you." This is the great reversal of God's kingdom. Down is the way up. Death leads to life. Losing yourself means finding yourself. It's counter to everything the world teaches, but it's the consistent message of Scripture. God lifts up those who humble themselves. We see this pattern throughout the Bible. Joseph went from prison to palace. David went from shepherd to king. Mary went from obscure virgin to mother of the Messiah. And ultimately, we see it in Jesus. He humbled Himself to the point of death on a cross. Therefore God exalted Him to the highest place. The passage shifts focus from our relationship with God to our relationships with others. "Do not speak evil against one another, brothers." James has already addressed the destructive power of the tongue in chapter three. Here he applies it specifically to how we talk about fellow believers.
The Greek word for "speak evil" carries the idea of slander and defamation. This is malicious gossip. It's tearing others down with our words. And James says it's incompatible with being part of God's family. Notice he calls them "brothers." He's emphasizing the family relationship that should shape how we speak about one another. We're remarkably creative at justifying our gossip. We call it "venting." We frame it as "sharing concerns." We disguise it as "prayer requests." But if we're honest, much of what we say about others is simply slander dressed up in Christian vocabulary. We need to guard our speech because our words have power to build up or tear down.
When we judge and slander our brother, we're actually speaking against God's law and setting ourselves above it. The law he has in mind is what he earlier called the "royal law" of love. When we slander others, we're essentially saying that the command to love our neighbor doesn't apply to us. We can violate it with impunity because we've appointed ourselves as judges. There's one lawgiver and judge. Only God has the authority to make laws and to judge whether people have kept them. When we take it upon ourselves to judge and condemn others, we're usurping God's role. We're saying we're qualified to sit on the throne and pass final judgment.
James asks the obvious question. "But who are you to judge your neighbor?" The implied answer is nobody. You're not qualified. You don't have all the information. You can't see the heart. You don't know what factors have shaped this person's life and choices. And even if you could see everything, you're not the judge. This doesn't mean we abandon all discernment. Scripture calls us to evaluate teaching, to exercise church discipline, to help fellow believers recognize sin in their lives. But there's a massive difference between humble, loving correction and self-righteous judgment. One flows from genuine concern for another's spiritual welfare. The other flows from pride and the desire to feel superior.
The test is simple. When you talk about someone else, are you building them up or tearing them down? Are you expressing genuine concern or rehearsing their faults? Are you hoping for their repentance and restoration, or are you enjoying their failure? Your answer reveals whether you're exercising biblical discernment or engaging in sinful judgment.
James then turns to a third area where humility must shape our lives. "Come now, you who say, 'Today or tomorrow we will go into such and such a town and spend a year there and trade and make a profit.'" He's addressing the merchant class of his day. These were traveling traders who moved from city to city, buying and selling goods. They made detailed plans with complete confidence in their ability to execute them.
The problem isn't the planning itself. Planning is wise. God gave us minds to think ahead, to prepare, to make provision for the future. The problem is planning without reference to God. These merchants speak as if they're in complete control. They determine where they'll go, how long they'll stay, what they'll do, and what profit they'll make. God doesn't factor into the equation.
James exposes the foolishness of this approach with a simple question. "You do not know what tomorrow will bring." We don't control the future. We can't guarantee outcomes. We don't even know if we'll be alive tomorrow. The COVID pandemic reminded us of this reality in dramatic fashion. Millions of carefully made plans were canceled in an instant. We were confronted with our lack of control. Then James asks an even more penetrating question. "What is your life?" His answer is sobering. "For you are a mist that appears for a little time and then vanishes." Your life is vapor. It's here for a moment and then it's gone. This isn't meant to be depressing. It's meant to be clarifying. When you understand how brief your time on earth is, it changes your priorities.
The wise response is to plan with humility. "Instead you ought to say, 'If the Lord wills, we will live and do this or that.'" This isn't a magical formula. You don't have to say these exact words every time you make a plan. But your heart needs to have this posture. You need to acknowledge that God is sovereign over your future. You need to hold your plans with open hands.
This affects everything. Your career plans. Your retirement strategy. Your children's education. Your investment portfolio. All of it needs to be submitted to God's will. You can make wise plans. You should make wise plans. But you must do so recognizing that God may have different plans. And when He does, you need to be willing to change course. James calls the alternative what it is. "As it is, you boast in your arrogance. All such boasting is evil." Not foolish. Not misguided. Evil. When we plan as if we're in control, when we boast about what we're going to accomplish, when we live as if God's will is irrelevant to our decision making, we're engaging in evil. That's strong language, but it's biblical language.
The passage concludes with a verse that applies to everything James has just said. "So whoever knows the right thing to do and fails to do it, for him it is sin." This is the sin of omission. It's not just doing wrong things. It's failing to do right things. And the "right thing" James has in mind includes everything in this passage.
You've heard the call to submit to God. Failure to submit is sin. You've heard the command not to slander and judge others. Continuing to tear others down with your words is sin. You've heard the instruction to plan with humility, acknowledging God's sovereignty. Arrogant planning is sin. Knowledge increases responsibility.
This is where the rubber meets the road. Most of us know far more than we obey. We've heard countless sermons. We've read numerous books. We've studied Scripture. But how much of that knowledge has translated into action? How much of what we know has actually changed how we live?
The gap between knowing and doing is the measure of our spiritual integrity. And James says that when we know what's right but fail to do it, we're sinning. We can't claim ignorance. We can't plead that we didn't understand. We know what God requires. The question is whether we'll obey.
This passage calls us to authentic faith, to worshiping God in spirit and in truth. It demands that we examine our lives for areas of double-mindedness, for places where we're trying to serve two masters. It exposes our tendency to judge others while excusing ourselves. It challenges our illusion of control over our futures.
But it also offers hope. God gives grace to the humble. When we submit to Him, when we draw near to Him, He draws near to us. When we humble ourselves before Him, He promises to exalt us. The path to genuine spiritual life runs through humility, through acknowledging our desperate need for God and our complete dependence on His grace.
The question each of us must answer is simple. Will we continue in double-mindedness, or will we pursue wholehearted devotion to God? Will we keep judging others, or will we extend the grace we've received? Will we cling to our carefully constructed plans, or will we hold them with open hands, submitting to God's will?
James isn't offering suggestions. He's issuing commands. Submit to God. Draw near to Him. Stop slandering your brothers and sisters. Plan with humility. And above all, close the gap between what you know and what you do. Your knowledge of these truths means you're now accountable for living them out. The choice to obey is yours, but the consequences of disobedience are real.
This is the call to authentic Christian living. It's not easy. It requires constant vigilance against the pull of the world and the pride of our own hearts. But it's the only path to the life God intends for us. It's the way of true worship, of giving God what He deserves, of living as creatures who recognize their Creator's rightful claim on every aspect of their existence. May we have the courage to walk this path, the humility to acknowledge our need, and the faith to trust that God's way is always best.
The passage begins with a word that carries military weight. "Submit yourselves therefore to God." The Greek word here, hypotagete, was used to describe soldiers voluntarily arranging themselves under the authority of their commanding officer. This isn't coerced obedience but closer to a willing surrender. We choose to place ourselves under God's command because we recognize His rightful authority over our lives. Using the word "therefore," James is building on what he's just said about God giving grace to the humble. Submission flows from grace. We don't submit to earn God's favor. We submit because God has already shown us favor through Christ. This should impact the way that we approach spiritual disciplines and obedience.
The call to submit comes paired with another command. "Resist the devil, and he will flee from you." We can't resist the enemy in our own strength. That's the crucial connection. Submission to God precedes effective resistance against Satan. When we're under God's authority, we have access to His power. The devil must flee when confronted by someone who's aligned with God. This isn't complicated spiritual warfare theology. It's practical reality. The Christian life involves real spiritual opposition. But we're not left to fight alone or in our own power. We stand firm in God's authority, and the enemy has to retreat. He has no choice in the matter. Then James gives us this beautiful promise. "Draw near to God, and he will draw near to you." This is the language of the temple, of priests approaching the presence of the Lord. But under the new covenant, all believers have access to God's presence through Christ. When we move toward God, He moves toward us. This is relationship, not ritual. The question is whether we're actually drawing near. Are we spending time in prayer? Are we reading Scripture? Are we worshiping? Or are we treating God like a cosmic vending machine, approaching Him only when we need something? Drawing near means cultivating an ongoing relationship with the Lord. It means making space in our lives for Him.
But drawing near requires honesty about our condition. James doesn't mince words. "Cleanse your hands, you sinners, and purify your hearts, you double-minded." He's addressing the external and the internal. Our actions need to change. Our motives need to change. We can't clean ourselves, but we must come to God for cleansing. That word "double-minded" appears only in James. It literally means "two-souled" or "two-minded." It describes someone trying to serve two masters, attempting to have God and the world simultaneously. Jesus said this is impossible. You'll love one and hate the other. You'll be devoted to one and despise the other. Double-mindedness produces instability and spiritual disaster. The call to repentance intensifies. "Be wretched and mourn and weep. Let your laughter be turned to mourning and your joy to gloom." This sounds harsh to modern ears. We live in a culture that avoids guilt at all costs. We're told that any negative emotion about our sin is unhealthy. But Scripture presents a different picture.
Godly sorrow over sin is the path to genuine joy. When we truly see our sin for what it is, when we understand how it grieves God and damages our souls, appropriate grief follows. This isn't morbid introspection or self-hatred. It's honest assessment. It's taking sin seriously because God takes it seriously. The world offers a different kind of laughter and joy. It's the celebration of rebellion, the pride of self-sufficiency, the arrogance of thinking we know better than God. That laughter needs to stop. That false joy needs to be exposed for what it is. Only then can we experience the deep, lasting joy that comes from right relationship with God.
James concludes this section with a promise. "Humble yourselves before the Lord, and he will exalt you." This is the great reversal of God's kingdom. Down is the way up. Death leads to life. Losing yourself means finding yourself. It's counter to everything the world teaches, but it's the consistent message of Scripture. God lifts up those who humble themselves. We see this pattern throughout the Bible. Joseph went from prison to palace. David went from shepherd to king. Mary went from obscure virgin to mother of the Messiah. And ultimately, we see it in Jesus. He humbled Himself to the point of death on a cross. Therefore God exalted Him to the highest place. The passage shifts focus from our relationship with God to our relationships with others. "Do not speak evil against one another, brothers." James has already addressed the destructive power of the tongue in chapter three. Here he applies it specifically to how we talk about fellow believers.
The Greek word for "speak evil" carries the idea of slander and defamation. This is malicious gossip. It's tearing others down with our words. And James says it's incompatible with being part of God's family. Notice he calls them "brothers." He's emphasizing the family relationship that should shape how we speak about one another. We're remarkably creative at justifying our gossip. We call it "venting." We frame it as "sharing concerns." We disguise it as "prayer requests." But if we're honest, much of what we say about others is simply slander dressed up in Christian vocabulary. We need to guard our speech because our words have power to build up or tear down.
When we judge and slander our brother, we're actually speaking against God's law and setting ourselves above it. The law he has in mind is what he earlier called the "royal law" of love. When we slander others, we're essentially saying that the command to love our neighbor doesn't apply to us. We can violate it with impunity because we've appointed ourselves as judges. There's one lawgiver and judge. Only God has the authority to make laws and to judge whether people have kept them. When we take it upon ourselves to judge and condemn others, we're usurping God's role. We're saying we're qualified to sit on the throne and pass final judgment.
James asks the obvious question. "But who are you to judge your neighbor?" The implied answer is nobody. You're not qualified. You don't have all the information. You can't see the heart. You don't know what factors have shaped this person's life and choices. And even if you could see everything, you're not the judge. This doesn't mean we abandon all discernment. Scripture calls us to evaluate teaching, to exercise church discipline, to help fellow believers recognize sin in their lives. But there's a massive difference between humble, loving correction and self-righteous judgment. One flows from genuine concern for another's spiritual welfare. The other flows from pride and the desire to feel superior.
The test is simple. When you talk about someone else, are you building them up or tearing them down? Are you expressing genuine concern or rehearsing their faults? Are you hoping for their repentance and restoration, or are you enjoying their failure? Your answer reveals whether you're exercising biblical discernment or engaging in sinful judgment.
James then turns to a third area where humility must shape our lives. "Come now, you who say, 'Today or tomorrow we will go into such and such a town and spend a year there and trade and make a profit.'" He's addressing the merchant class of his day. These were traveling traders who moved from city to city, buying and selling goods. They made detailed plans with complete confidence in their ability to execute them.
The problem isn't the planning itself. Planning is wise. God gave us minds to think ahead, to prepare, to make provision for the future. The problem is planning without reference to God. These merchants speak as if they're in complete control. They determine where they'll go, how long they'll stay, what they'll do, and what profit they'll make. God doesn't factor into the equation.
James exposes the foolishness of this approach with a simple question. "You do not know what tomorrow will bring." We don't control the future. We can't guarantee outcomes. We don't even know if we'll be alive tomorrow. The COVID pandemic reminded us of this reality in dramatic fashion. Millions of carefully made plans were canceled in an instant. We were confronted with our lack of control. Then James asks an even more penetrating question. "What is your life?" His answer is sobering. "For you are a mist that appears for a little time and then vanishes." Your life is vapor. It's here for a moment and then it's gone. This isn't meant to be depressing. It's meant to be clarifying. When you understand how brief your time on earth is, it changes your priorities.
The wise response is to plan with humility. "Instead you ought to say, 'If the Lord wills, we will live and do this or that.'" This isn't a magical formula. You don't have to say these exact words every time you make a plan. But your heart needs to have this posture. You need to acknowledge that God is sovereign over your future. You need to hold your plans with open hands.
This affects everything. Your career plans. Your retirement strategy. Your children's education. Your investment portfolio. All of it needs to be submitted to God's will. You can make wise plans. You should make wise plans. But you must do so recognizing that God may have different plans. And when He does, you need to be willing to change course. James calls the alternative what it is. "As it is, you boast in your arrogance. All such boasting is evil." Not foolish. Not misguided. Evil. When we plan as if we're in control, when we boast about what we're going to accomplish, when we live as if God's will is irrelevant to our decision making, we're engaging in evil. That's strong language, but it's biblical language.
The passage concludes with a verse that applies to everything James has just said. "So whoever knows the right thing to do and fails to do it, for him it is sin." This is the sin of omission. It's not just doing wrong things. It's failing to do right things. And the "right thing" James has in mind includes everything in this passage.
You've heard the call to submit to God. Failure to submit is sin. You've heard the command not to slander and judge others. Continuing to tear others down with your words is sin. You've heard the instruction to plan with humility, acknowledging God's sovereignty. Arrogant planning is sin. Knowledge increases responsibility.
This is where the rubber meets the road. Most of us know far more than we obey. We've heard countless sermons. We've read numerous books. We've studied Scripture. But how much of that knowledge has translated into action? How much of what we know has actually changed how we live?
The gap between knowing and doing is the measure of our spiritual integrity. And James says that when we know what's right but fail to do it, we're sinning. We can't claim ignorance. We can't plead that we didn't understand. We know what God requires. The question is whether we'll obey.
This passage calls us to authentic faith, to worshiping God in spirit and in truth. It demands that we examine our lives for areas of double-mindedness, for places where we're trying to serve two masters. It exposes our tendency to judge others while excusing ourselves. It challenges our illusion of control over our futures.
But it also offers hope. God gives grace to the humble. When we submit to Him, when we draw near to Him, He draws near to us. When we humble ourselves before Him, He promises to exalt us. The path to genuine spiritual life runs through humility, through acknowledging our desperate need for God and our complete dependence on His grace.
The question each of us must answer is simple. Will we continue in double-mindedness, or will we pursue wholehearted devotion to God? Will we keep judging others, or will we extend the grace we've received? Will we cling to our carefully constructed plans, or will we hold them with open hands, submitting to God's will?
James isn't offering suggestions. He's issuing commands. Submit to God. Draw near to Him. Stop slandering your brothers and sisters. Plan with humility. And above all, close the gap between what you know and what you do. Your knowledge of these truths means you're now accountable for living them out. The choice to obey is yours, but the consequences of disobedience are real.
This is the call to authentic Christian living. It's not easy. It requires constant vigilance against the pull of the world and the pride of our own hearts. But it's the only path to the life God intends for us. It's the way of true worship, of giving God what He deserves, of living as creatures who recognize their Creator's rightful claim on every aspect of their existence. May we have the courage to walk this path, the humility to acknowledge our need, and the faith to trust that God's way is always best.
Recent
Archive
2025
January
May
July
2024
January
October
2023
February
March
Categories
no categories
No Comments